Five-hour Kleftiko with Feta Cheese

kleftiko with feta cheese

I’m afraid this recipe doesn’t feature British cheese and that this time I didn’t make the feta myself (although after last year’s home-made feta slime-fest I think my family are probably quite glad). I was going to write a very exciting cheese post but under-estimated how long that particular ‘recipe’ would take to reach its conclusion, so instead I bring you what I had for Sunday lunch: Kleftiko, slow-cooked for five hours with feta cheese.

Now, I’m always a bit scared of posting classic recipes on here for fear of the online beating I may get; everyone has their own take on recipes, sometimes handed down through the generations and sometimes memorised from a yellowing copy of Good Housekeeping in 1978 and NOTHING ELSE WILL DO. My favourite comment on my blog so far was when I made and posted a version of Bajan Macaroni Pie and, although I explicitly stated that I was well aware that everyone had their own version and that various ingredients were hotly debated, someone still kindly took the time to tell me in no uncertain terms everything that I’d done wrong (which was everything) and comment that the topping ‘looks like a yeast infection’ (you’re obviously more familiar with them than me, love…)

Apparently ‘Kleftiko’ is Greek for ‘stolen meat’ and the story is that it would be a dish made by bandits who would steal a lamb and then cook it for a long time, sealed with mud in a hole underground so that no-one would suspect anything. So, here is my version of Kleftiko and very nice it was too. And yes, I know that your Gran from Skopelos would never have used cinnamon and that I have cooked it for too long/not long enough/not in the ground in the back garden. And I’ve probably used the wrong herbs or the wrong cheese or the wrong cut of meat. And I’m not really a bandit. But look, it tasted good. So there.

In fact, blame this chap because I used his recipe as a starting point. Go and pick on him instead.

Ingredients (this will serve 4 very greedy people)

Olive oil, for frying and general drizzlage
4kg lamb shoulder, bone in
16 cloves of garlic, peeled and crushed
A handful of herbs such as oregano, thyme or rosemary (I used whatever I could find lurking in the garden at this time of year)
Juice of 6 lemons
1 tsp ground cinnamon
200g feta cheese, crumbled into chunks

Preheat the oven to 140°C/120˚C fan-assisted/Gas Mark 1. Rub olive oil all over the meat and season with salt and pepper, then seal it on all sides in a hot pan.

kleftiko with feta

Put a long piece of baking paper in a roasting tray, so that it hangs over the edges (I used more than double the size of the tray). Put the lamb, garlic, herbs and lemon in the middle of the paper and sprinkle the cinnamon over.

kleftiko with feta

Seal the baking paper around the edges, scrunching it up to make a parcel.

kleftiko with feta

Roast the meat for 4½ hours. After this time, open up the parcel and scatter over the feta chunks.

kleftiko with feta

Baste with the meat juices and cook for 20 minutes more. The meat will be gloriously tender even if you were sold a bit of old mutton like I suspect I was and the lemony-garlicky juice with chunks of feta in makes the perfect sauce.

kleftiko with feta


Filed under Cheese Recipes

22 responses to “Five-hour Kleftiko with Feta Cheese

  1. Oh yum, that looks mouth-watering. I’ve slow-cooked lamb before but not to this recipe. I’ll have to give this a go.

  2. People actually tell you you have cooked something the wrong way?! I would say if you cooked something and it tasted good….. that’s what it’s all about, isn’t it? I dunno lol.

  3. After living in Greece for nearly 15 years, I have tried many versions of kleftiko – no two are quite the same, and yours looks very tasty! And let’s face it, can feta cheese ever really be wrong when added to a Greek dish?!

  4. That cracked me up. Who doesn’t have a hole in the backyard and that special clay/water/terroir/air for that special recipe. On the other hand, I made an offhand remark about kale on a blog post that wasn’t really kale related, and someone took exception to that. Oops. It felt like being told to shush in the cinema. 😉

  5. andreamynard

    Looks wonderful and I’m very tempted to give it a go – with a bit of old mutton. I bet the slow cooking would suit it!

  6. Yum yum! I love the combination of lamb and feta.

  7. Excellent post! Made us laugh and drool at the same time…not ver becoming we assure you!

  8. Ah I love kleftiko – almost forgotten that it exists (how can you?!) Thank you for the reminder 🙂

  9. I think people that don’t realise that food can improve when people put their own slant on stuff are destined to eat the food of their grandmothers. Which is all well and good if your grandmother is Mary Berry, or Darina Allen. My grandmother was a bloody terrible cook, who would crumble an oxo cube into hot water and call it either gravy or tea, depending on what receptacle it was served in.
    Those people should also remember that when our grandmothers were learning to cook, we had rationing, so I think they’re missing out. 😉
    Thanks for this recipe, it looks brilliant, no matter what the mythical grandmothers might claim.

  10. Lamb….yum….feta….yum….lamb and feta….yum yum!

  11. Pingback: Yorkshire Curd Tart | Fromage Homage

Leave a Reply to FromageHomage Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s