Not Very French Onion Soup with Lincolnshire Poacher Toasts

french onion soup with lincolnshire poacher cheese

If life gives you lemons, make lemonade. If life gives you onions, make…er…bhajis? But bhajis aren’t renowned for their cheesiness (although I’m sure you could probably whack a bit of paneer in there with great results) and so, when I mucked up on a grocery order and found myself with the Mount Kilimanjaro of onions, French Onion Soup it was. Typically French Onion Soup is topped with melted gruyère and so I mused upon British cheese and thought of Lincolnshire Poacher. Poacher is made to a recipe loosely based on West Country cheddar but is also influenced by Swiss mountain cheeses due to the starter culture that’s used. The result is a smooth Gruyère-like texture but with the nutty, grassy taste of a mature Cheddar. Perfect melty cheese.

I initially took the recipe for this soup from The Slow Cook Book by Dorling Kindersley but then I got a bit fretty when my onions weren’t doing much so I consulted Delia’s Winter Collection for reassurance. It turned out well, the onions beautifully sweet and the top a mess of lovely cheesy soggy toast. Go easy on the brandy though unlike me.


30g butter
1 tbsp olive oil
675g onions, thinly sliced
1 tsp caster sugar
salt and pepper
120ml dry white wine
2 tbsp plain flour
1.5 litres hot beef stock
4 tbsp brandy (one per bowl, or to taste)
1 garlic clove, chopped in half
4 slices of baguette, about 2cm thick, toasted
115g Lincolnshire Poacher cheese, grated

Melt the butter and oil in a pan over a low heat. Stir together the onions and sugar and season with salt and pepper.

french onion soup with lincolnshire poacher cheese

Cook uncovered, stirring every now and then, for about 40 minutes, or until the onions are rich and brown (this bit took me more like an hour). Don’t let them stick and burn on the bottom.

french onion soup with lincolnshire poacher cheese

Stir in the wine. Increase the heat a tad and stir for five minutes, to glaze the onions. Sprinkle in the flour and stir for two minutes. Stir in the stock and bring to the boil. Reduce the heat to low, put the lid on and leave it to simmer for 30 minutes. Taste and adjust the seasoning as required.

french onion soup with lincolnshire poacher cheese

Meanwhile pre-heat the grill. Divide the soup between four flameproof bowls and stir 1 tbsp of brandy into each (do this to taste; mine was a bit over-brandied). Rub the garlic clove over the toast and place one slice in each bowl. Sprinkle with the cheese and grill until the cheese is bubbling and golden.

french onion soup with lincolnshire poacher cheese

Sweet soup with a cheesy topping is pretty darn comforting, I’d say, and so I’m linking it up with this month’s Cheese, Please! Challenge.

Fromage Homage


Filed under Cheese Recipes

16 responses to “Not Very French Onion Soup with Lincolnshire Poacher Toasts

  1. Phwoar! That looks like exactly the sort of comfort food I need!

  2. One of my all-time favourites when it comes to comfort food. I must try Lincolnshire Poacher again, as a Lincolnshire lass; I thought it was a bit mouse-trappy but maybe I had an unlucky wedge.

  3. Looks perfect for a long winter’s evening. I’ve never had it with wine and brandy before: must try!

  4. I’ve shied away from making French Onion Soup for years now. It’s a disaster every single time I try to make it!! You actually have me tempted to try your recipe… this is lovely.

  5. I love it when you make the most of mistakes, and this looks like a really tasty one 🙂

    If you ever have too many onions again, might I suggest onion marmalade? It’s the perfect accompaniment to cheese and crackers!

  6. Debbie Spivey

    Very nice!

Leave a Reply to linnetmoss Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s